10 Best Eyeliners Of 2026
Eyeliners — Reviews, Recommendations & Updated Buying Guide September 2026
Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner
Why We Love It
Maybelline New York Liquid Eyeliner
Why We Love It
Maybelline New York Colossal Eyeliner with Argan Oil
Why We Love It
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer
Why We Love It
RIMMEL Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer Pencil
Why We Love It
Rimmel London Wonder Ink Eyeliner 02 Spiced Chestnut
Why We Love It
Essence Eyeliner Pen Waterproof - 01 Black
Why We Love It
Essence Liquid Ink Eyeliner Waterproof 01
Why We Love It
LAKMÉ Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner
Why We Love It
Essence STAY & PLAY GEL EYELINER 07
Why We Love It
Quick Pick
10 Best Eyeliners Of 2026
Quick Pick
Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner, Black, 3g | 3g
Maybelline New York Liquid Eyeliner, Brush Tip, Long-Lasting and Waterproof, Matte Finish, Hyper Easy Liner, Black
Maybelline New York Colossal Eyeliner with Argan Oil, Matte, Black, Pencil
Rimmel London Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer, 001 Intense Black, 0.35g
RIMMEL Scandaleyes Exaggerate Eye Definer Pencil, 002 Chocolate Brown, 0.35g
Rimmel London Wonder Ink Eyeliner 02 Spiced Chestnut
Essence Eyeliner Pen Waterproof - 01 Black, 77217, 0.03 Fluid Ounce | Waterproof, long-lasting hold, definition, eyeliner
essence Liquid Ink Eyeliner Waterproof 01
LAKMÉ Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner, 4.5 ml, Black
essence STAY & PLAY GEL EYELINER 07
Buying Guide: Eyeliners
📋 Table of Contents
1What's the difference between liquid, pencil, and gel eyeliners?
Liquid liners offer the most precision and boldest lines, pencils are easier to blend and more forgiving for beginners, while gel liners sit between them with good control and a smoother finish. Your choice depends on the look you want and your skill level—precision seekers prefer liquid, those who like softer lines choose pencil, and people wanting durability often go for gel.
2How long should an eyeliner last before it runs out or dries up?
Most pencil eyeliners last 6-12 months with regular use, while liquid and gel formulas can last 3-6 months since they dry out faster once opened. Storage matters—keep caps sealed tightly and store away from direct heat to extend the life of any formula.
3What should I look for to avoid eyeliner that smudges easily?
Check the product label for waterproof or smudge-proof claims, and look for formulas with silicone or polymers that help them stay put. Gel liners tend to smudge less than pencils, and liquid liners are generally the most smudge-resistant option.
4Is it worth buying expensive eyeliner brands over budget options?
Premium brands often have better pigment payoff, longer wear time, and smoother application, but many affordable liners perform just as well—it's worth testing a budget option first. Spend more if you have sensitive eyes or need professional-grade precision; otherwise, try cheaper versions to see if they meet your needs.
5What kind of eyeliner works best for sensitive or easily irritated eyes?
Look for eyeliners labeled hypoallergenic, dermatologist-tested, and free from harsh chemicals like parabens and fragrance. Pencil liners are often gentler than liquids, and cream or gel formulas tend to cause fewer irritation issues than waterproof variants.
How we choose
Our editors are people who genuinely love testing and writing about products. We compare each product's real-world usability and strengths, then distill what matters most into our own "Why We Love It" points — so you get an honest, at-a-glance sense of what counts before you buy.